TORINO RAFFAELE
Objectives
Through the historical-comparative method, the course aims, in the first part, to provide students with the tools to analyze and understand different concepts of law and different ways to legitimate the law in the main legal traditions (Civil law, Common law, legal systems of Islamic countries, main Asian legal systems, South American legal systems). In the second part, the course aims to deepen the historical-comparative aspects of the European integration process and the evolution of the Chinese legal system.Risultati Apprendimento Attesi
By the end of the course, students will be able to:– understand the concept of “legal system” and distinguish the main contemporary legal traditions (civil law, common law, religious and Asian legal systems);
– conduct a comparative analysis of sources of law, the role of judges, the doctrine of precedent, and methods of legal reasoning across different systems;
– explain the differences between models of constitutional review, the Rule of Law, and the continental concept of the constitutional state (Rechtsstaat);
– identify processes of legal transplants, circulation of legal models, and legal pluralism;
– apply comparative legal categories to concrete cases and contemporary issues (fundamental rights, regulation, soft law, law and religion);
– use the technical vocabulary of comparative law accurately and appropriately.
Programme
1. What Is Law? Normativity and Legitimacy2. Functions and Conceptions of Law
3. What Is a Legal System? Structure and Elements
4. Law and Justice: Antigone, Legality, and Civil Disobedience
5. Fundamental Rights and Levels of Protection
6. The Trial as a Rationalization of Conflict
7. Ius Commune and the Jurists’ Law
8. Canon Law and Methodological Transformations
9. Modern Natural Law and Codification
10. Legal Positivism and the Model of the Code
11. Origins and Structure of the Common Law
12. Precedent and Stare Decisis
13. Vertical and Horizontal Precedent
14. Judicial Style and Techniques of Legal Reasoning
15. Ratio Decidendi and Obiter Dictum
16. Equity in the English Legal System
17. Equity in Continental Legal Systems
18. Modern Constitutions and the Rise of Constitutional Review
19. Models of Constitutional Review in Comparative Perspective
20. The Constitutionalization of Private Law
21. Legal Realism and Critical Legal Studies
22. Soft Law, Regulation, and Independent Authorities
23. The Rule of Law in the English Tradition
24. Rechtsstaat and the Constitutional State Governed by Law
25. The European Rule of Law
26. Judicial Systems and Legal Professions
27. The Jury and Alternative Dispute Resolution
28. Islam and Law
29. The Chinese Legal System
30. Post-Colonial Legal Systems and Legal Pluralism
31. The Japanese Legal System
Prerequisiti
No specific prerequisites are required. A basic knowledge of public law and fundamental legal concepts is recommended.Core Documentation
They will be indicated at the beginning of the lectures.Attendance
RecommendedType of evaluation
Assessment consists of a written examination and an oral examination. The written exam is designed to verify knowledge of the fundamental concepts, comparative categories, and main differences between the legal systems studied during the course, as well as the ability to apply them to short questions or case-based prompts. The oral exam aims to assess the command of technical legal terminology, argumentative skills, the ability to draw connections between different legal models, and the student’s critical comparative analysis.Esempi Domande
1. Explain the main differences between civil law and common law with regard to sources of law, the role of judges, and the authority of precedent.2. Analyse the meaning of the Rule of Law and compare it with the continental concept of the constitutional state governed by law (Rechtsstaat), highlighting any structural differences.
3. Define the concept of ratio decidendi and distinguish it from obiter dictum. Discuss the interpretative challenges involved in identifying the binding part of a judicial decision.